In the realm of hiring strategies, one Australian executive’s unconventional approach has ignited a digital wildfire of debate. Trent Innes, hailing from Melbourne, Australia, has been thrust into the spotlight as his unorthodox evaluation technique, known as the “coffee cup test,” takes center stage on social media platforms. The four-year-old interview where he first unveiled this method has resurfaced, sparking fervent discussions among netizens.

In 2019, during his tenure as the Managing Director at Xero, an accounting software company, Trent Innes divulged his covert personality test on “The Venture Podcast with Lambros Photios.” This 16-minute episode, titled “The Secret Job Interviewing Hack to Recruit the Right Staff,” shed light on Innes’s peculiar evaluation process.

The essence of Innes’s methodology lies in the simple gesture of offering job interview candidates a cup of coffee or another beverage upon their arrival at the office kitchen. However, it’s what happens next that separates the contenders from the pretenders.

Candidates who, at the conclusion of their interview, neglect to return their empty cups to the kitchen find themselves at a disadvantage in Innes’s eyes. He believes that this test serves as a litmus test for a potential employee’s attitude, an essential factor that transcends skills and experience.

Innes elaborated during the podcast, stating, “You can develop skills, you can gain knowledge and experience, but it really does come down to attitude, and the attitude that we talk a lot about is the concept of ‘wash your coffee cup.'”

Naturally, Innes’s method has its share of proponents and critics. Social media platforms such as TikTok, Facebook, and Reddit have been abuzz with discussions over the validity and fairness of the coffee cup test.

One TikTok user questioned the appropriateness of washing one’s own cup during an interview, stating, “I feel like it’s weird to wash your own cup at an interview when you’re a guest there. I’d prob just ask what they want me to do with the cup.”

Another user pointed out the location’s significance, adding, “If [we’re] still in the kitchen yes but if we in a conference room and I leave I’m not walking around the office again. I don’t work there yet.”

Some users outright rejected the idea, with one stating, “I wouldn’t even take the cup in the first place honestly.”

Critics argue that the coffee cup test is an inadequate measure of a candidate’s suitability. One user explained, “I understand the spirit behind it, given that I hate people not clearing up after themselves but it’s not a fair or accurate way of testing people.”

The debate extends to the broader implications of such a test on workplace dynamics. Some question whether this method creates unnecessary tension during the interview process and whether it reflects the manager’s communication style and expectations.

In March, Reddit became a platform for deliberation on this very topic. Users shared their perspectives, with one advocating for common courtesy, stating, “If someone drank the coffee and just left the mug sitting on the bench, I’d probably judge them a bit for it too.”

However, another user questioned the hygiene aspect, quipping, “Well, ‘boss,’ I was hoping the cup my lips just touched wasn’t gonna be hand washed in a dirty office sink and put out for the next candidate.”

This debate shines a light on the diverse array of interview techniques utilized by hiring managers. While some see value in unconventional approaches, others emphasize the importance of focusing on tasks, compensation, and team dynamics.

In the end, the coffee cup test remains a polarizing subject in the world of job interviews, leaving candidates and hiring managers alike pondering the true essence of a good fit for a workplace culture.

Download our app MadbuMax on the Apple App Store for the latest news and financial tools. Interested in getting your finances in order do not forget to check Dr. Paul Etienne’s best-seller book on personal finance. To access more resources, tools, and services please click here. Also, do not forget to follow Dr. Etienne on IG or Twitter.